Lisa Howard

as Linda Gufstafson and Gladys Turnakit

Sims Lamason

as Lorraine Stubenski

Catherine Ashmore Bradley

as Little Lorraine/Dori

Graham Stevens

as Trip

Will Boyajian

as Dov Yisrael

Doug Shapiro

as Bob/Coach Ivan

Paige Sommerer

as Deacon Andrea Doekstra

Nick Abbott

as David, Jimmy and Alan Thicke

Micah Mims

as Ray-Ray

Alia Munsch

as Tammy and Stephanie